The new Dr. Horrible on the rise… in me?
If you ever ask me, I will say “people suck. I hate people.” The truth is that I don’t really hate people. It is the shield I wrap around myself because I am constantly being let down by people, because deep down, I believe that people are good. And when I keep seeing people go out of their way to prove me wrong, to prove that people are not good, I get so hurt, that it is easier to just put up that crispy outer shell and say “people suck. I hate people.”
Joss Whedon, who is my favorite TV writer, recently created and released a web show called “Dr. Horrible’s Sing-A-Long Blog”. It chronicles the rise of a new super villain from his geeky, hapless start, showing how he became the seemingly heartless super villain he ends up being. I love the music, and the acting and the singing. And the writing is full of Whedon’s trademark wit… the kind that you may not catch the first time through, but that is so clever, that every time I find one, I am more impressed with his nuanced style.
The thing that draws me in the most, though, is the thing that always draws me in to a Joss Whedon story… and that is the realness of the characters. You will never find a character who is purely good or purely evil in any of his stories. You may be a horrible snake demon who wishes to devour an entire graduating class, but come on people, let’s use clean language. You may be a superhero who always saves the day, but you’re still a lousy girlfriend. You may be a vampire who wants to turn all of mankind into a walking juice box, but you still want to keep your family together. Those who know Joss’s work will recognize the Buffy references here. There are a billion examples of this from Buffy, Angel and Firefly, and I expect to see them in the upcoming Dollhouse as well.
But here in Dr. Horrible, they are never more clear. He says again and again “the world is a mess”. Now, his plan to fix it is to dominate and rule it. But he is coming at his goal of world domination from a good place in his heart. He wants to make the world a better place. He is clearly misguided, and he is clearly doing unethical things. However, as you watch the show, you find yourself rooting for him to succeed, to conquer the superhero, to get the girl.
And this superhero! Sure, he’s doing good deeds, but it is not from a desire to save the world. Here is a “hero” who is really a self-aggrandizing, womanizing bully. So what if he is stopping a heist? He is beating up a geek who is no match for him physically. He is stealing the girl, not because he wants her, but because his nemesis does. He is helping people to impress the girl, to be loved and admired. Not for the sake of good.
And so, as I struggle in my own little life with people and attitudes that are morally and ethically the opposite of my own, I find myself becoming more and more resentful of them. The world is a mess. People are sneaky and manipulative. They are taking advantage of people. They are doing things that, maybe don’t hurt mankind, but certainly don’t help either.
I see the character of Penny in Dr. Horrible. She is this bright-eyed idealist. In her eyes, the world is getting better. People are trying harder. People are helping each other. And in her, “rapture is on the rise”. For me, I don’t see it. I can’t get there from here.
I see the character of Dr. Horrible. And he is jaded. And to his perspective, people are getting worse. People are selfish. People are manipulative. And the only way he sees of improving the world is to rule the world and bend it to his will. I find myself wishing I had the ability to do just that. If *I* were in charge of the world…. (sigh).
I had a conversation with a coworker today that involved an almost weekly pep-talk about how to get from where I am to “rocking” in the eyes of the company without selling my soul. And he basically tried to teach me how to manipulate people. This is always his response. He doesn’t say it like that… but it is “here’s how to present your ideas and cover your ass, you look like a rock star, and you make them look like idiots.” He wants me to be Captain Hammer (corporate tool).
I can’t be Penny. I’m shown again and again that people are not getting better but worse.
So my choices: Dr. Horrible or Captain Hammer. Super villain with a broken soul, or Super Hero without a soul. Both seem like prices too high to pay.
It feels more like I’m headed for another option: mindless drone. Sidekick. Do as you are told. Do not examine the moral or ethical dilemma. Do what your super hero or super villain authority figure tells you. So I find myself in the position of Moist. “At my most bad-ass, I make people want to take a shower.” That’s what I’ve got. At my most powerful, I make people feel ever so slightly guilty about continuing to manipulate and trick people. And nothing changes.
Where does one enroll to get a PhD in Horribleness?